Series: Cartridges of the World, 9th ed
Paperback: 512 pages
Publisher: Dbi Books; 9th Rev edition (December 2000)
Product Dimensions: 1 x 8.2 x 10.5 inches
Shipping Weight: 2.6 pounds
Average Customer Review: 4.5 out of 5 stars See all reviews (94 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #2,727,470 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #51 in Books > Crafts, Hobbies & Home > Antiques & Collectibles > Firearms & Weapons > Ammo & Grenades #799 in Books > Crafts, Hobbies & Home > Antiques & Collectibles > Firearms & Weapons > Firearms #2765 in Books > Crafts, Hobbies & Home > Antiques & Collectibles > Antiques Care & Reference > Reference
artridges of the World, authored by Frank C. Barnes and edited by Stan Skinner, is always a fun read and generally a good reference book, however, I believe the franchise publishers may be getting a little impatient in releases. The 11th edition was released only 10 months after the 10th edition, while the 10th edition was released almost 3 years after the 9th edition and with more appropriate timing based on new cartridge releases. In short, there wasn't much new included that shouldn't have easily made the 10th edition.In general, I noticed no particular attempt by the author to update or correct entries that appeared in earlier editions. The 357 SIG is still listed as a new cartridge , with the suggestion that time will tell if it will succeed. The 357 SIG is chambered in almost every performance non 1911 autoloader and in heavy use with Federal agencies including air marshals and the FBI. The 376 Steyr carries an association with the Scout rifle which has not been available in that chamber for years. The Remington SAUM line and the WSM line read like a new introductions. There are some showcase articles on sub .22 caliber rifle cartridges and the Chinese standardization on the 5.8 caliber, although I am hard pressed to know why as the information is of little practical use and of interest to a very limited audience. I would have been happier with a review of the concepts behind the past few years of cartridge releases and the prospects for the future.Some of the categorizing or editing has gotten a little sloppy and there is a decent amount of redundancy in listings.
Cartridges of the World ReviewFirst of all, most of what I'm going to say relates to Edition nine, but is designed to tie in with comments made by "Spartiate" below. I felt his/her comments deserved a reply, because they echo thoughts I had when I first bought Edition nine.I had thought Edition Nine was an excellent advance on what I'd read before, with a few low patches. Previous editions I'd seen were two and five, when John Amber and Frank Barnes reigned supreme. Nine certainly has vastly more information, and I'm curious as to whether Ten has that much more again.I agree with certain criticisms, particularly the repetition within the entries on the Lazzeroni and JDJ cartridges. It seemed to me (with my more limited knowledge) that the editor was trying to fill space while talking about new cartridges that didn't (yet!) have much history worth speaking of. A collated expose on those companies that offered various proprietary cartridges, with the odds and sods at the end listed by calibre, might have been better and allowed a lot less repetition of somewhat less relevant material.I didn't examine the handloading data very carefully, not being actively engaged in the sport myself, and can't comment on errors. What I did think was a shame was the numerous horrendous typographical errors, omissions and "tab-stop disasters" present especially within the British Cartridges section. From this viewpoint, some of the older editions were better.Inconsistencies from one edition to another are also apparent, e.g. Barnes's comments on the .32 Winchester Special and the rifles which fire it have been COMPLETELY RUBBISHED in the most scathing tones by the editor in the 9th edition.
Cartridges of the World (Cartridges of the World, 9th ed) Cartridges of the World: A Complete and Illustrated Reference Source for over 1500 of the World's Sporting Cartridges (8th Edition) Sixgun Cartridges and Loads: A Manual Covering the Selection, Use and Loading of the Most Suitable and Popular Revolver Cartridges Manual of Patent Examining Procedure: 9th Ed. (Vol. 6): Original Ninth Edition (MPEP Original 9th Edition) (Volume 6) Cartridges of the World: 10th Edition, Revised and Expanded Cartridges of the World, 6th Edition Cartridges of the World, 5th Edition Cartridges of the World (7th ed) Burnside Breechloading Carbines and Rifles: A Collectors Guide to The Firearms and Cartridges Invented by The Famous Civil War General, Ambrose E. Burnside A Handbook of Civil War Bullets & Cartridges US Army Technical Manual, ARMY DATA SHEETS FOR CARTRIDGES, CARTRIDGE ACTUATED DEVICES AND PROPELLANT ACTUATED DEVICES, FSC 1377, TM 43-0001-39, 1991 Abnormal Psychology in a Changing World (9th Edition) Statistics for Management and Economics (with Online Content Printed Access Card) 9th (ninth) Edition by Keller, Gerald (2011) Marx Trains Pocket Price Guide, 9th Edition (Greenberg's Guides) Lab Manual for Andrews' A+ Guide to IT Technical Support, 9th Edition How Computers Work (9th Edition) Lab Manual for Andrews' A+ Guide to Software, 9th Issues in Internet Law: Society, Technology, and the Law, 9th Edition West's Business Law Texts and Cases: Legal, Ethical, International, and E-Commerce Environment, 9th Edition My iPhone (Covers iOS 9 for iPhone 6s/6s Plus, 6/6 Plus, 5s/5C/5, and 4s) (9th Edition)