File Size: 3673 KB
Print Length: 160 pages
Publisher: Random House (October 23, 2012)
Publication Date: October 23, 2012
Sold by: Random House LLC
Word Wise: Enabled
Lending: Not Enabled
Enhanced Typesetting: Enabled
Best Sellers Rank: #352,055 Paid in Kindle Store (See Top 100 Paid in Kindle Store) #17 in Books > Cookbooks, Food & Wine > Entertaining & Holidays > Thanksgiving #94 in Kindle Store > Kindle eBooks > Cookbooks, Food & Wine > Special Occasions > Holidays #341 in Books > Cookbooks, Food & Wine > Entertaining & Holidays > Holidays
This is one instance when I want to distract you from the number of stars I give the book, because depending on what you're looking for, the rating is either "absolutely 5 stars" or "not so much."Sam Sifton's _Thanksgiving: How to Cook It Well_ has a very clear goal: to make the traditional what-we-grew-up-with Thanksgiving meal the best it can possibly be. Without question, it succeeds. However, it gives no attention, none, to alternatives, let's-try-something-different, or what to serve vegetarians. If you want suggestions on how to liven up the old turkey-and-dressing meal, look elsewhere. Really. You'll be completely disappointed.But oh, OH, it is so good at what it sets out to do. As Sifton writes, "It is a primer on how to face down the Thanksgiving meal. It should provide you with solace as you face the terrors of your first Thanksgiving or the boredom of your 26th." Solace: That's the ticket. Because even if Thanksgiving is the High Holy Day to us foodies, it's a huge meal to prepare for people who are not into cooking, not to mention them coping with stress of the family politics of who is talking to whom, and the subjects we hope Uncle Harry *won't* bring up. Sifton promises: "You can make a better turkey than anyone has ever served you in your life. You can serve it with dressing that makes your guests swoon."He has very clear ideas on what it takes to make the meal (the day, really) a success, starting of course with the menu. And this is where the expectations come in: The recipes he provides are for the super-traditional Thanksgiving dinner. That means turkey, no alternate suggestions. It means the side dishes you can tick off on your fingers -- mashed potatoes, green beans, brussels sprouts, cornbread dressing -- without a lot of options.
I must agree with the author when he writes, "Thanksgiving is not a book for everyone. It is not for those in search of the new Thanksgiving craze, the latest recipe for turkey in a bag, the next big trend in holiday entertaining. There will be no recipes here for ham or lamb, roast beef or swordfish... You will make a turkey. Turkey is why you are here." He has a very strong opinion of what Thanksgiving is and allows no room for deviation. There will be no appetizers and no salad.As other reviewers have noted, if you want a primer on an old-fashioned Thanksgiving with turkey, sides and dessert (AND you don't already have a Thanksgiving cookbook), this might be worth considering (although I encourage you to check out other Thanksgiving books first). If you already have a Thanksgiving cookbook (perhaps The New Thanksgiving Table or The Thanksgiving Table: Recipes and Ideas to Create Your Own Holiday Tradition), I doubt you will get much from this.If you want recipes for a traditional meal with alternatives for loved ones who follow a vegetarian, gluten-free or low-fat diet, this book is not for you. Although the author mentions fielding questions on the New York website including what to feed a vegan aunt, there is no consideration given to alternative diets in the book.There are also no photos, only a handful of sketches.
As Thanksgiving provides comfort food, Sam Sifton has provided comfort reading in this small, but packed-full little reader. Would I call this a recipe book? Not sure, but it certainly does contain all the recipes a newbie would need to whip up their first Thanksgiving . But it's more than just recipes, and that is what I love about it. The author talks about each component of the meal, and also reminisces about past holidays which gave me the same feeling as when I think back to some of my favorite past Thanksgivings as well. We all tend to have that ideal vision, either from a past event of our own, or from a magazine page or movie scene. We hold it in our hearts and do what we can to recreate it year after year. Regardless of how the food comes out or who shows up at our door, we need to remember that part of the joy comes from our state of mind. This book helps put you in that good place.There are plenty of cookbooks out there with full-color photos, so if that is what you are looking for, this is not that kind of recipe book. There are just a few black and white sketches (the publisher should have put more, they add charm and fit so well with the author). But if you want the feel of a favorite relative or friend sitting with you over coffee or a glass of wine and sharing with you their old recipe box filled with tried and true classics, this is the book for you. Grab a warm drink and snuggle up on the couch with this book. You'll feel the spirit of Thanksgiving upon you.It starts with, of course, Getting Started - and talks about the basic supplies, pans, and tools you will need. I have been very happy to see that most of what a do is in sync with the author. I was worried it was going to be ultra Martha Stewart and I would think, oh, forget this. But it's not.
Thanksgiving Recipes - Top 200 Thanksgiving Recipes (25 Vegan, 25 Paleo, 25 Gluten Free, 25 Low Carb and 100 Traditional Recipes, Thanksgiving Cookbook) Thanksgiving: How to Cook It Well: How to Cook It Well The Thanksgiving MEGAPACKTM: 35 Holiday Classics for Thanksgiving How to Cook Everything Thanksgiving Thanksgiving Is for Giving Thanks (Reading Railroad) The First Thanksgiving (Step-Into-Reading, Step 3) Bright Baby: Happy Thanksgiving Cranberry Thanksgiving (Cranberryport) Thanksgiving Is... Thanksgiving Turkey Trouble (Ready, Freddy!) Holiday Recipes: 25 Easy and Delicious Recipes for Celebrating Thanksgiving and Christmas Southern Holiday Feast: Thanksgiving, Christmas, New Year's, Easter & More! (Southern Cooking Recipes Book 27) The Complete Holiday Treats Cookbook: Easy to make Goodies for Halloween, Thanksgiving, and Christmas The Little e-Book of Raw Vegan Holiday Recipes: 50 recipes for Halloween, Thanksgiving, Hanukkah, Kwanzaa, Christmas, New Year's Eve, and New Year's Day Brunch Thanksgiving Cookbook (Classic Cookbooklets) Thanksgiving Crockpot Recipes: Cooking For A Stress Free Holiday Slow Cooker Thanksgiving: 21 Recipe for a Perfect Holiday (Healthy Recipes, Crock Pot Recipes, Slow Cooker Recipes, Caveman Diet, Stone Age Food, Clean Food, Holiday Food) Thanksgiving Tales: True Stories of the Holiday in America Easy Thanksgiving: 8 Restaurant Side Dishes New Thanksgiving Table