Hardcover: 960 pages
Publisher: Phaidon Press; 1St Edition edition (September 17, 2010)
Product Dimensions: 7.5 x 2.2 x 11.2 inches
Shipping Weight: 3.5 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 4.4 out of 5 stars See all reviews (84 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #38,040 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #13 in Books > Cookbooks, Food & Wine > Asian Cooking > Indian #496 in Books > Cookbooks, Food & Wine > Regional & International #5018 in Books > Teens
Phaidon should be ashamed of releasing this book in its current state (especially proclaiming "Quality Assurance" on the cover). Although, as other reviewers have pointed out, this book is beautifully designed, it is so poorly edited and indexed that each time I pick it up I encounter a new glaring error. Problems include:- Recipes are printed twice, one after the other, e.g. Mirchi ka Salan (p. 319 & 320) and Matar Paneer (p. 315 & 316)- Recipes do not appear in the index, e.g. Keeme ke Samose / Lamb Samosas (p. 209)- Recipes are not indexed intelligently. Most types of dishes are not listed together in the index, for example you cannot look up "samosa" or "kebab" in the index and see a list of the different recipes for that type of dish, you will find only the recipes that begin with that word, e.g. Kebab Cooked on a Stone is listed under "kebab" but not Roasted Lamb Kebabs. In an 800 page book with 1000 recipes where the index is the only way to find recipes (there is no table of contents for each section) the terrible indexing job is unforgivable.In addition, the author has made several mistakes that nearly sabotage what is obviously a labor of love and the product of a tremendous amount of research. First of all, the recipes are poorly written and have many oddities and omissions. Pigeon Peas in Rice Konji (p. 542) has no rice mentioned anywhere. As another reviewer pointed out, the recipe for Mirchi ka Salan / Stuffed Green Chillies is comically flawed: the chillies are never stuffed. This is even more egregious given that this recipe is pictured and it would be impossible to follow the recipe as is and produce something vaguely resembling the photo.
As an avid collector of Indian cookbooks in particular, I have rarely come across a collection that is encyclopedic, rigorous in sticking to the classic recipes as well as meticulous about pinpointing their regional origins. This book manages to do it all. I can't speak much about the author, as the traditional "about the author" section seems to be missing in this book, save for a 2-page color photo spread.That said, the design, the weight, the color coding and the sparse and accurate descriptions are generally a pleasure. For the novice new to Indian cooking, you will find a good overview of the various regions, but once you dive into the actual recipes themselves, there isn't much guidance on the nuances of the techniques, other than the standard description of the method.
I had heard about this book on chowhound.com and was very excited about it because I love Pushpesh Pant's food oriented work. I own another of his books, food Path: Grand Trunk Road from Kabul to Kolkota, which I love and have cooked from a lot. India: The Cookbook is excellent. The recipes are very authentic, homemade type stuff, and they look very good. I love it and can't wait to try out a few recipes. I am so sick of books which claim to be real-deal Indian cooking but the recipes are very restaurantish and not really what Indian food is like in people's homes, or books which claim to represent Indian cuisine, but it is clear that the recipes are very specific to how dishes are made in the author's region, yet this is never mentioned. The only way to really learn the myriad of Indian cuisines is by understanding regionality, and differences in cuisine within regions based on ethnolinguistic or religious community. India: The Cookbook doesn't really delve into ethnicity/religion in cuisine much, though is occasionally mentioned. But India: The Cookbook contains many, many recipes from all of India's major regions. Among the specific regions included in the book are Jammu-Kashmir, Punjab, Delhi, Awadh, Coastal (Pant lumps together the Western Coast states, occasionally specifying which), Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad, Bengal, and a few others.I am not Asian, but my husband's family is from Pakistan (originally from Northern India), so getting good, authentic recipes is very important to me, as I cook South Asian cuisine at least a few times each week and like to cook a large range of dishes rather than eating the same thing all of the time.
Caste, Society and Politics in India from the Eighteenth Century to the Modern Age (The New Cambridge History of India) Indian Philosophy: Volume I: with an Introduction by J.N. Mohanty (Oxford India Collection) (Oxford India Collection (Paperback)) Ramayana: India's Immortal Tale of Adventure, Love and Wisdom: India's Immortal Tale of Adventure, Love, and Wisdom Alberuni's India. An account of the religion, philosophy, literature, geography, chronology, astronomy, customs, laws and astrology of India about A.D. 1030 VOL. 1 A History of the Sikhs: Volume 2: 1839-2004 (Oxford India Collection) (Oxford India Collection (Paperback)) Captains File: India: From Nayudu to Kohli, India's Test Cricket Captains Crock Pot: Everyday Crock Pot and Slow Cooker Recipes for Beginners(Slow Cooker, Slow Cooker Cookbook, Slow Cooker, Slow Cooker Cookbook, Crockpot Cookbook, ... Low Carb ) (Cookbook delicious recipes 1) Beyond Curry Indian Cookbook: A Culinary Journey Through India India: The Cookbook The Kerala Kitchen: Recipes and Recollections from the Syrian Christians of South India (Hippocrene Cookbook Library) The Complete Asian Cookbook Series: India & Pakistan Island Style Cookbook: Guam's Favorite Soups, Tasty Guam Recipes, Wonderful Chamorro Island Food , Exotic Guam Cookbook Of Soups, Enjoy Awesome Chamorro Guam Food From This Island Cookbook Easy Vietnamese Cookbook: 50 Authentic Vietnamese Recipes (Vietnamese Recipes, Vietnamese Cookbook, Vietnamese Cooking, Easy Vietnamese Cookbook, Easy Vietnamese Recipes, Vietnamese Food Book 1) Chinese Cooking: No Wok Takeout! 80 Amazingly Delicious 3 Steps Or Less Chinese Recipes Revealed (Chinese Cookbook, Cooking For One) (cookbook for beginners, ... meals cookbook, easy meals for one 2) Crockpot Recipes: 30 Delicious, Dairy & Gluten Free, Low Carb Recipes For Busy People (Slow Cooker, Slow Cooker Cookbook, Crockpot Cookbook, Gluten Free ... Cooker Recipes, Low Carb Cookbook Book 1) Easy Tomato Sauce Cookbook: 50 Delicious Tomato Sauce Recipes (Tomato Sauce, Tomato Sauce Cookbook, Tomato Sauce Recipes, Italian Cookbook, Italian Recipes Book 1) Salads - Top 200 Salad Recipes Cookbook (Salads, Salads Recipes, Salads to go, Salad Cookbook, Salads Recipes Cookbook, Salads for Weight Loss, Salad Dressing Recipes, Salad Dressing, Fruit Salad) Rice Cooker Recipes: The Ultimate Rice Cooker Cookbook: The Best Quick And Easy Rice Cooker Recipes You Can Make At Home Tonight (Rice Cooker Cookbook, ... Recipes, Rice Cookbook, Rice Recipes) CROCK POT: 450 Easy Crockpot Recipes (crockpot cookbook, slow cooker recipes, crock pot meals, paleo, vegetarian, crock pot, crock pot cookbook, crockpot freezer meals, slow cooker cookbook) TEX-MEX COOKBOOK Tex-Mex Takeout Cookbook: Favorite Tex-Mex Recipes to Make at Home (Texas Mexican Cookbook)